TL;DR
Consumers are increasingly choosing Stumptown’s Cold Brew with Oatly over Starbucks, citing comparable quality at a lower cost. This shift is driven by the product’s taste, price, and convenience, leading some to abandon drive-thru coffee.
Consumers are increasingly opting for Stumptown’s Cold Brew with Oatly over Starbucks, with some reporting they are ditching the drive-thru coffee chain entirely for this at-home alternative.
Stumptown Coffee Roasters’ Cold Brew with Oatly Variety Pack has become a popular choice among coffee drinkers seeking high-quality, affordable, and convenient cold brew options. The variety pack, which includes three flavors—Chocolate, Horchata, and Original—costs around $13, making each carton roughly $4.33, less than a typical Starbucks Tall.
Reviewed by a consumer, the product delivers a robust coffee flavor combined with creamy oat milk and a touch of sweetness, comparable to or exceeding the quality of many drive-thru offerings. The Horchata flavor, with its cinnamony note, has been particularly well-received, offering warmth without heaviness. The consumer noted that the product’s flavor and price point have led her to prefer it over her previous Starbucks routine.
While the product’s popularity is rising, it is unclear how widespread this shift is or whether it will sustain long-term consumer behavior. The trend appears to be driven by the product’s taste, affordability, and convenience, especially amid rising coffee costs and increased interest in at-home coffee options.
Why Consumers Are Choosing Cold Brew Over Starbucks
This shift reflects broader changes in consumer behavior, with many seeking cost-effective, high-quality alternatives to Starbucks. It highlights how premium at-home coffee options can influence traditional coffee shop patronage, potentially impacting Starbucks’ sales and prompting other brands to innovate or lower prices. The trend also indicates a growing preference for convenient, ready-to-drink cold brews that match or surpass coffee shop quality, especially amid economic pressures and changing lifestyles.
Stumptown Coffee Roasters, Coffee Cold Brew Oatly Original, 11 Fl Oz
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Rise of At-Home Coffee Choices and Market Trends
Stumptown Coffee Roasters has been a key player in specialty coffee since the late 1990s, emphasizing direct trade sourcing. Their Cold Brew with Oatly Variety Pack has gained popularity for offering quality, variety, and affordability. Consumer interest in high-quality, ready-to-drink cold brews has grown, especially during the pandemic era, as more people seek convenient options. This trend is part of a broader shift away from traditional coffee shop visits toward at-home alternatives, driven by rising costs and lifestyle changes.
“I’ve completely stopped going to Starbucks; this cold brew is just as good, if not better, and way cheaper. It’s become my go-to now.”
— an anonymous consumer
Cold Brew Mason Coffee Maker – 64oz Iced Coffee Pitcher with Stainless Steel Mixing Spoon & Super Dense Filter 3 Steps Finish Cold Brew Coffee, Classic BPA Free Sturdy Mason jar Pitcher Easy to Clean
[3 Steps Save 2000$]: Included in the package is a mixing spoon and instructions to help make it…
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Extent and Sustainability of Consumer Shift
It is not yet clear how widespread this shift away from Starbucks is or whether it will be sustained long-term. Consumer preferences may fluctuate, and broader market factors could influence future trends.
SToK Bold & Smooth Black Unsweetened Cold Brew Coffee, Ready to Drink Bottled Coffee, 48 fl oz
Bold & Smooth Cold Brew: 48 fl oz bottle of black and unsweetened SToK Cold Brew; 125 mg…
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Future of Cold Brew Market and Consumer Preferences
Market analysts expect continued growth in premium at-home cold brew products, with more brands potentially offering similar or improved options. Starbucks and other coffee chains may adapt by emphasizing quality, price, or convenience to retain customers. Monitoring consumer behavior will reveal whether this trend persists or evolves.
Oatly Barista Edition Oat Milk – Crafted for Coffee | Dairy-Free, Plant-Based, Shelf-Stable Milk that makes Perfect Foam (32 oz, 12-pack)
YEP, THE SAME ONE YOUR BARISTA POURS: Get the professional-grade Oatly you love to sip at cafes, now…
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Key Questions
Is the Stumptown Cold Brew with Oatly pack available nationwide?
Availability may vary by region, but the product is widely sold online and in select stores. Check local retailers or online platforms for access.
How does the flavor compare to Starbucks cold brew?
According to consumer reviews, the flavor is comparable or superior, with added variety and a more affordable price point.
Can I store the cartons at room temperature?
No, the cartons should be refrigerated upon arrival and kept cold to maintain freshness and safety.
Are there any allergens in these cold brews?
The products contain oat milk, which is a common allergen. Consumers with oat or dairy allergies should check ingredient labels carefully.
Will this affect Starbucks’ sales significantly?
It is too early to determine the overall impact, but rising consumer preference for at-home options could influence Starbucks’ sales in certain markets.
Source: The Kitchn
